Filks and parody

[javasaurus]

My understanding of "parody" as applied to copyright is not the commonly held understanding. Not every comedic or critical use of a work is parody for purposes of copyright! Parody can constitute fair use, but for it to be fair use, it needs to make fun of (or otherwise comment on) the work being modified. So creating alternate lyrics to Nirvana's "Smells like teen spirit" that make fun of the president would generally not be fair use, even if it is, more generally, parody. To parody a song you have to be making a statement about that song itself, or it's not fair use.

Am I right? If you disagree, please provide links to support your argument. In the meantime, Family Guy is getting sued for modifying "When you wish upon a star."

Comments

[wilhelmina-d.livejournal.com]

I believe that you are correct, though my knowledge of that subject is admittedly miniscule.

Still, shame about Family Guy.

[blueeowyn.livejournal.com]

This is interesting because one of the people I read has recently prompted discussion on covering a song and the rights to that. My understanding is that legally a band can cover a song but must pay for the right to cover it but the right cannot be denied (subject to certain 'right of first performance/recording issues' I think).

It is considered wrong to reuse an arrangement w/out paying (and for certain areas of music it is assumed that your style evolved from certain well known styles such as Baltimore Consort and Bare Necessities (I think) and thus you are expected to pay them a license fee.

Now if you change the words to a song to make fun of the song, that would be parody pure and simple (though that line can get blurry at times).

If you change the words to modernize a song (e.g. New York Gilbert & Sullivan Players changing the list of people on the list) is that OK?

Where is the line?

[skimbells.livejournal.com]

commenting very late.... but..... as "when you wish upon a star" is a disney piece, and disney is not known for going lightly in these matters